Assessment in math is about making decisions: how I use what I observe in class to help every student move forward

Laura Morera
15/10/2026|8 min read
Assessment in math is about making decisions: how I use what I observe in class to help every student move forward

Assessment is a complex task. But if we rely only on the final assessment, we arrive too late to help our students. Because assessment is much more than giving grades. It is a process that starts on the first day of class, stays with us throughout learning and helps us understand what is happening in the classroom.

That is why, when people ask me what assessment means, I always give the same answer:

Assessment means gathering evidence and making decisions that help every student keep learning.

In this article, we will look at how to gather that evidence and use it to give meaning to what we do in the classroom.

What does a grade really tell us?

A grade on its own sums up a lot but explains very little. Giving a number quantifies how much a student knows. Grading well, on the other hand, means describing what they know and how they can apply it. And this is where the difference between two ways of assessing comes in.

On the one hand, summative assessment comes at the end and looks mainly backwards. On the other, formative assessment goes hand in hand with learning and looks forward, gathering information so that we can step in while there is still time.

But it is not about choosing one or the other. For me, good assessment has to be formative and summative at the same time, and it has to be present throughout the whole school year.

Learning to look

During my PhD, I analyzed a huge number of videos of my own lessons. It was as uncomfortable as it was enriching, because I learned to see what was really happening in the classroom, beyond what I thought was happening.

And that is where I learned something I now consider essential: the first place where assessment happens is the classroom itself. For students to truly learn math, we need to create opportunities for deep learning. That requires pace, activities with a clear purpose and good questions. And, above all, knowing how to listen. Because many of our most important decisions come out of the conversations that happen in class.

During my stay at the Freudenthal Institute, I came across a metaphor by researcher Paul Drijvers that has stayed with me ever since:

A teacher is less like the conductor of a symphony orchestra, where every note is decided in advance, and more like the leader of a jazz band.

— Paul Drijvers

The leader arrives with a general score prepared, but leaves room for the musicians to improvise. And to improvise well, you have to know how to listen.

I remember one lesson in particular. I had posed a problem in which students had to generalize a pattern and, working in pairs, they came up with different algebraic expressions. They were the ones who were surprised: “It’s strange that we got different things, when we both think we did it right.”

I had to react quickly. I realized that they were all right: some had simplified their expressions further and others had interpreted the pattern geometrically in a different way. Instead of giving them the answer, I used the situation to open a class discussion. I kept asking questions until they themselves concluded that, although the expressions looked different, they were equivalent.

That is assessment too: listening to what happens in the classroom and knowing when to step in, when to ask and when to let students keep talking.

What mistakes tell us

But not all evidence shows up in classroom conversations. Of course, we also find it in notebooks, in tests and in the data from individual practice. And very often, it is mistakes that give us the best clues about how to step in.

I remember a student who kept getting 57 × 18 wrong. When I looked through his notebook, I noticed that he always went wrong at the same point: there was a step of the algorithm that he had not really understood. Spotting it in time meant I could work with him one-on-one for a few days, until he was able to do it correctly. If you think about it, a grade would have told me he was getting it wrong, but the notebook helped me understand why.

Something similar happens with individual practice data. When students practice, the Classroom Manager lets me see, for example, which times tables each student has mastered and which ones they find harder. Once, I noticed that a student was taking a long time to estimate sums. When I watched how he did it, I discovered that he first calculated the exact result and then rounded it. That gave me the chance to work with him on number sense for estimation: anticipating roughly what result we can expect before calculating.

And sometimes the evidence tells us less about our students than about the way we teach. I remember a test in which almost the whole class struggled to justify how they had reached a solution. That was evidence too, but this time it was about me. In the following lessons, I changed my approach and started asking them to explain out loud how they had arrived at their results.

Assessing content and reasoning

So what should we pay attention to when we assess? For me, there is a key balance between mastery of content and mathematical reasoning. Both matter, and each needs the other.

In education, we have seen the pendulum swing many times. For a long time, the focus was almost exclusively on content. And when we started to give more importance to problem solving, connections and reasoning, we sometimes set aside things we were already doing well. Without a solid foundation of content, it is hard to reason or connect ideas. But repetitive practice without understanding what we are doing does not take us very far either.

Research shows that we need to work on both. And this has a direct consequence for assessment: we need to pay attention both to what students know and to how they use that knowledge.

That is why, for example, I check fluency specifically. If I notice that many students are struggling with their times tables, I give a targeted quiz and prepare a times-table workbook with challenges for those who need more practice. But I am also interested in tasks that let me see how students reason, how they connect ideas and how they justify their answers.

A wider view: the class, the year and the whole journey

So far, we have talked about gathering evidence to understand each student’s learning. But when you have a class of 25 or 30 students, doing this individually is not always easy. That is why the more tools we have to gather, analyze and interpret this information, the easier it will be to make decisions and give each student useful feedback.

One example is Conmat Adaptive Benchmark, a set of math assessments that show us where students stand at the beginning and at the end of the school year. They are multiple-choice tests taken in a single session that assess both content and the ability to solve problems, reason and connect ideas.

The September test focuses on the previous year’s content, while the May test covers the current year’s. This means the second one is more demanding, so we cannot compare the scores directly as if they were the same test: we are looking at two moments in learning with different expectations.

The interesting part comes when we analyze the results. The report shows how students are distributed across four levels (low, lower-middle, upper-middle and high), how many have changed level over the year, and in which strands, such as number, measurement or geometry, the class shows more strengths or difficulties. We can also compare the percentage of correct answers with the average for schools that use Innovamat. These tests have also been psychometrically validated in collaboration with experts from the Bellvitge Biomedical Research Institute (IDIBELL).

But this view should not be limited to a single year. Ideally, we would be able to follow and observe each student’s progress throughout their entire school journey, to understand not only where they are at a given moment, but also how they got there and how we can help them keep moving forward.

Assessing to help every student go further

When we talk about intervention, we almost always think of the students who find math harder. And that makes sense. In the classroom, we can do a lot to help them: ask questions that guide them, use materials that help them understand abstract concepts, or adapt activities to their needs.

But not everything depends on what happens in class. The report Everything That Matters in Learning Mathematics, by Lucas Gortázar and Marc Colomer, points out that family is the factor most strongly associated with learning outcomes. That is why it is important for families, other teachers and everyone who supports the student to pull in the same direction.

That said, the same report highlights an idea I find essential: the factor with the greatest influence is not necessarily the one we can act on the most. And within the school, one of the most powerful levers is the teacher. So, even though many factors are involved, much of what we can do ends up happening in the classroom. The decisions we make based on what we observe matter, and they matter a lot.

And in those decisions, we cannot forget the emotional side either. It is important to help students understand that every small step forward counts and that a difficulty does not have to become a block. I always tell them:

“It’s not that it’s hard; it’s that you don’t know how to do it yet.”

But assessment also means paying attention to those who move ahead easily. Students who are doing well also need opportunities to keep growing. We can offer them extension questions, challenges that start from the same activity but go one step further, or opportunities such as math competitions.

Because, in the end, assessment is not just about spotting who needs help, but also about discovering how far each student can go and giving them opportunities to get there.

Assessing in order to act

Gathering evidence takes time, and with large classes it is not always possible to do it in as much detail as we would like. On top of that, knowing how to interpret it and decide what to do with it requires professional learning: mastering mathematics, how to teach it and classroom management, and continuing to learn throughout our teaching career.

Tools can help us gather and analyze information, but none of them replaces the teacher’s eye. Because, in the end, assessment is not just about having more data, but about knowing what to do with it.

And that, for me, is the key to good assessment: observing, making decisions and acting while there is still time to help our students. When we see it this way, it stops being an end-of-term formality and becomes an essential part of learning.

If you would like to know more about what has to happen in a classroom for real learning to take place, I talk about it in the interview “The Class of My Life.”

And you? Can you remember a time when what you observed in class made you change your plans?

Related reads